Extreme Ultraviolet Spectroscopy
of the Solar Corona
Giulio Del Zanna
A thesis submitted in
partial fulfilment
of the requirements
for the degree of
Doctor of Philosophy.
Centre for Astrophysics
University of Central Lancashire
July 1999
A thesis dedicated to the memory of Brunella
Monsignori Fossi.
Abstract
New Extreme Ultra-Violet (EUV)
observations of the solar corona, obtained by the
Coronal Diagnostic Spectrometer (CDS) instrument on board
the NASA/ESA Solar and Heliospheric Observatory (SOHO)
are presented.
The CDS instrument for the first time has provided
the opportunity of observing a large number
of emission lines from a wide
range of ions of different elements.
The spectral and spatial
resolution of the CDS instrument has allowed
the simultaneous application of a wide range of
spectroscopic diagnostic techniques to determine the
temperature distribution, densities and
elemental abundances in the solar plasma.
A differential emission measure (DEM) diagnostic technique has been
used to infer the temperature structure
and the element abundances. The importance of including
DEM effects in the element abundance analysis is demonstrated.
A complete in-flight cross-calibration
between all the CDS detectors (NIS and GIS, 150-785 Å),
is presented here for the first time.
The level of accuracy and completeness of the CHIANTI atomic database,
used throughout this thesis, has allowed the
identification
of the many hundreds of spectral lines observed
in the CDS spectra, resulting in several new line identifications.
An assessment of the GIS solar spectra is presented,
showing that, in spite of complexities,
GIS spectra are useful for diagnostic analyses.
Many discrepancies (in particular with the Li-like ions)
between theory and CDS observations are highlighted.
It is shown that
some of these may be explained by inaccurate ionization equilibrium calculations.
Coronal hole densities, temperatures, DEMs, and relative element abundances
from both off-limb (plume and inter-plume regions)
and on-disc observations are derived and
compared with quiet sun values.
These included (August 1996) a large equatorial hole, the Elephant's Trunk,
probably the best example of a coronal hole observed by SOHO.
Coronal hole densities in both coronal
(Ne @ 1 x108 cm-3)
and transition region (Ne @ 1 x1010 cm-3)
plasma were found to be about a factor of 2 lower than in the quiet sun,
with much lower emission measures at temperatures above 106 K.
Moreover, in the transition region, the cell-centres in both
coronal holes and quiet sun regions show consistently
higher densities (factor of 2) compared to
those in the network.
Relative element abundances show approximately photospheric values
for the coronal holes, with an indication of element abundance
variation (neon in particular) with the supergranular structure.
On-disc EUV observations
of coronal hole plumes have been performed.
This allowed a spectroscopic characterisation of plumes to be obtained for the
first time, leading to the first identification of a
low-latitude plume near sun-centre.
Plumes are shown to be quasi-isothermal structures, with temperatures
T @ 7-8 x105 K.
Abundance analyses (using transition region lines)
reveal a small FIP effect in these plumes,
together with a decreased
Ne/O abundance ratio (compared to photospheric).
Acknowledgments
I wish to thank all the many people and institutions that
with their support helped me during the course of my PhD.
These include, with no particular order:
my first and second
supervisors, Barbara and Gordon Bromage for their support
and guidance throughout this period.
The University of Central Lancashire for a three-year
full-time research studentship, which
supported my work and living expenses during that time.
In particular, the Centre for Astrophysics for
additional financial support for some of my trips.
All the local organising committees and agencies (NATO in particular)
that funded
my many trips to summer schools, meetings, and congresses.
Deianira. Without her help during the last year, I would have not been
able to finish on time.
Barbara Hassall and Ken Phillips for having accepted the task of
examining me, and for reading this rather long thesis.
Massimo Landini for his precious collaboration and support
from the very beginning.
Enrico Landi, a good collaborator and companion
during the many conferences I went to.
Helen Mason, Ken Dere and Peter Young for
stimulating discussions and collaborations.
Andy Adamson and Pete Newman, for their
continuous support as system managers,
during a difficult period including office and building moves
and disruptions.
[Much of the data reduction, processing and analysis detailed in this thesis
has been done with the Interactive Data Language (IDL)
and using STARLINK facilities].
The whole of the CDS operation staff at RAL (UK) and GSFC (USA)
for their assistance
and hospitality during visits there.
In particular: Richard Harrison and Dave Pike for their assistance
in the planning and execution of the observations;
Bob Bentley, without whom most of the Elephant's Trunk coronal hole
observations would have not been taken place;
Andrzej Fludra, for the stimulating
collaboration in working with CDS and in producing results.
William Thompson, Eddie Breeveld for their technical support.
Stein Vidar Haugan, for his much appreciated
support regarding CDS data analysis and IDL programming.
Sarah Gibson and Douglas Biesecker for the collaboration for the
Whole Sun Month Campaign, and support for the attendance of the
related workshops.
Barbara Thompson and the EIT consortium for providing
the EIT images.
Marta, for her continuous moral support and great
long-distance long-lasting friendship.
Vincenzo, for his excellent hospitality and friendship.
Susanna, for an excellent friendship and for cheering me up
when I needed.
All the many colleagues and friends, with whom I shared an
enjoyable social life in these years.
These include (it is virtually impossible to
mention all of them): Christophe, Fiona, Eleonora, Andy, Alessandro,
Agostino, Vinicio, Katerina, Marianna,
Dalila, Nathalie, Turandot, Julia, John, Francesca,
Bill, Gabriel, Cormac, Carl, Guillaume, Till, Emmanuel,
Carina, Chris, Mark, Pete, Laurence, Lucia, Barbara, Alice, Mikko,
Pedro, Maria (2).
I would also like to thank Janey. With her, I learned
much, including english.
Finally, I thank my father and all my family,
for their help and support when I needed it.
This thesis is dedicated to the memory of Brunella
Monsignori Fossi.
She suddenly
died the morning of monday 22nd January 1996, in front of her
terminal. She spent long part of her active life studying the
coronae of cool stars and the sun, and in the last years
in preparation for SOHO.
I had the opportunity, working closely with her, in Arcetri,
to appreciate her qualities outside research.
She would have very much enjoyed
studying the solar corona with SOHO and CDS, as I did.
In the following, you can find links to
the (g-zipped) postscript files of each Chapter.
Note that:
- The postscript files were created in order to
be printed in duplex.
- The links to the Sections are not active yet.
- Most contents of the thesis are not published
elsewhere, so the proper reference is
G. Del Zanna, PhD thesis, Univ. of Central Lancashire UK (1999)
-
Contents.
This file contains the above abstract,
the acknowledgments and the contents.
-
Introduction
-
An introduction to the theory of emission from
coronal plasmas
-
Temperature determination
-
Electron density estimates
-
General considerations of the plasma equations
-
Previous observations of the solar corona
-
Ground and space observations of the solar corona
-
Space observations pre-SOHO
-
Space observations: SOHO
-
General coronal hole characteristics
-
Temperatures
-
Temperatures from in-situ charge state measurements
-
Temperatures above the limb from white light observations
-
Temperatures from Lya profiles
-
Limb observations from EUV intensities
-
Disc observations and emission measure analysis
-
Temperatures from filter ratio techniques
-
Densities
-
Element abundances
-
Coronal plumes
-
pre-SOHO observations.
-
Theoretical models.
-
SOHO observations
-
Critical discussion of spectroscopic diagnostic techniques
and their application to CDS data
Note: Some contents of this Chapter have been published in
various journals.
-
Electron density diagnostics
-
Comments on the lines in Table 2.1
-
Some other density-sensitive ratios with problems
-
Concluding comments
-
The L-function method of determining electron density
-
The electron temperature evaluation. The isothermal case
-
The electron temperature evaluation. The DEM method
-
The inversion technique developed to calculate the DEM
-
A comparison of various emission measure methods, using Skylab
coronal hole data
-
Some historical approaches.
The EML, EMT, DEML approximations
-
The emission measure loci approach
-
The Pottasch (19663) approach
-
The Jordan (1971) approximation
-
A different approach. The DEML method
-
Results of the DEM approach, basic definitions and comparison with the DEML method.
-
The element abundances evaluation. Comparison of the DEM
with the DEML method.
-
Discussion of the results and comparison with previous analyses
-
The shape of the DEM and the element abundances
-
The problem with the Li-like ions and other lines
-
The element abundance evaluation.
Critical discussion of previous work and assessment of the CDS
possibilities
-
The potential of CDS for determining abundances
-
The CDS instrument. Data analysis and calibration
Note: Most contents of this Chapter have been published in
A&A.
The second order GIS calibration presented here
was offset by a factor of two. This has been corrected
in the paper.
-
The normal incidence spectrometer
-
Subtraction of the CCD bias
-
Cosmic ray removal
-
Corrections for flat-fielding, burn-in and
nonlinear effects, using VDS_CALIB
-
Correction for geometric distortions, using VDS_ROTATE
-
Spatial resolution and binning along the slit
-
Line-fitting
-
Error estimates.
-
The intensity calibration
-
The grazing incidence spectrometer
-
Fixed patterning and line profiles
-
Ghosts
-
The wavelength calibration
-
The intensity calibration
-
The first-light GIS observations
-
The calibration of the CDS instrument
-
The diagnostic method for the CDS calibration
-
The diagnostic method
-
Applicability of the method
-
Layout of the rest of Section 3.4
-
The SERTS-89 spectrum
-
A GIS internal intensity calibration study
-
The GIS study presented in Landi etal (1999a)
-
The revision of the active region spectrum
-
The NIS observations for the internal intensity calibration
-
The on-disc active region observation of 25th September 1997
-
The observations for the NIS-GIS cross-calibration
-
The rationale for special observing sequences
-
Observation sequences and data analysis
-
The overlapping regions between the CDS channels
-
The lines of the same ion seen in different channels
-
Ghosting and the reconstruction of some lines
-
The NIS and GIS spectra of the quiet sun observations
-
The physical characteristics of the off-limb (1997 May 4) and on-disc (1997 October 16)
regions
-
The NIS 1 internal calibration
-
The NIS 2 internal calibration (first order)
-
The transition region and chromospheric lines
-
The coronal lines
-
Other lines
-
Concluding comments on the NIS 1 and NIS 2 sensitivities
-
The cross-calibration between all the NIS and GIS channels, first and second order
-
Cross-calibration between the NIS 1 and GIS 2
-
Cross-calibration between NIS 1 and GIS 1
-
Cross-calibration between NIS 1 and GIS 3
-
Cross-calibration between the NIS 1 and NIS 2
-
On-disc cross-calibration between NIS 2, GIS 3, GIS 4
-
Cross-calibration between NIS 1 and GIS 4 (first and second order)
-
Other cross-calibrations (first and second order)
-
Final results and comments
-
The off-limb observation of May 4th 1997. The effect of different
calibrations and ionization equilibrium calculations.
Full list of identified lines
-
A comparison of different ionization equilibrium calculations
-
The line identifications and the theoretical spectra
-
The GIS ghosts
-
The on-disc observation of October 16th 1997.
Full list of identified lines
-
Observations and data analysis
-
Some of the CDS studies used or developed
-
The observations during August-September 1996
-
The Whole Sun Month (WSM) campaign
-
The Elephant's trunk
-
The observations during September-October 1997
-
Off-limb observations of polar holes (February - April and October 1997)
-
The software developed for the data analysis
-
Results for coronal holes, quiet sun and plumes
Note: Some contents of this Chapter have been published in
various journals.
-
General characteristics of off-limb densities and temperatures for the
quiet sun and polar coronal holes from 1996 to 1998
-
Off-limb observations of the equatorial regions
-
Polar coronal holes
-
Results from near-disc-centre observations, 1996 August
-
The results from the Elephant's Trunk observations of the 26th August 1996
-
Results from the quiet sun reference observation - 1996, Aug 25
-
Coronal hole and plume densities, temperatures and abundances - 1996 August 27
-
The spectra and DEM of the Elephant's Trunk coronal hole
-
The DEM of the low-latitude plume
-
The GIS E-W scan across the hole: abundance variations
-
An example of coronal hole GIS spectra
-
Intercomparison and summary of the near-disc-centre results
-
Results for polar coronal holes and polar plumes
Note: Some contents of this Chapter have been published in
various journals.
-
On-disc observations of polar holes
-
The October 10th 1997 observations of a polar coronal hole region, with a
plume, quiet sun, and a bright point
-
Observations of the quiet sun - coronal hole boundary
-
Off-limb observations of polar holes and plumes
-
The off-limb coronal hole observations of the 12th of September 1997
-
The off-limb observations of 1998 February 9
-
The GIS cross
-
Polar plumes observed on-disc
-
Results for a polar plume observed on 1996 August 23
-
Results for a polar plume observed on 1997 October 11
-
The DEM of the plume area
-
Comparison of GIS spectra with EIT (1997 October 11 data)
-
Conclusions and further work
-
Summary of results and conclusions
-
Spectroscopic diagnostic methods and the CDS
-
Solar physics results and conclusions
-
Further work
-
Atomic physics studies
-
Short-time-scale events
-
Coronal holes, the transition region and the plumes
-
References
-
Appendices
-
The results for SERTS-89
-
The CDS observations (1996-1998)
-
The calibration of the CDS instrument
-
The observations for the CDS calibration
-
The spectra and line identifications for the off-limb observation - May 4th 1997
-
The GIS ghosts for the off-limb observation - May 4th 1997
-
The spectra and line identifications for the on-disc observation - October 16th, 1997
-
The GIS ghosts for the on-disc observation - October 16th 1997
-
Appendix to Chapter 5. CDS spectra of the Elephant's Trunk coronal hole
-
Appendix to Chapter 6
-
Spectra and line identifications - plume observation - October 11th 1997
Back to my research home
page
Back to my home
page
Back to the Atomic
Astrophysics homepage at DAMTP
Giulio Del Zanna May 2003